
This is a summary of a recent Veterans survey made by a Salle Angelo fencer for Fencing NZ. It should be of interest to other older fencers regardless of whether they fence visual, electric, or both. 80 names of all those aged 40 and over, with their contact details, were extracted from the Fencing NZ affiliation database. This included fencers who are no longer affiliated. A questionaire was emailed or mailed out to these names and 42 people replied. Of these, 28 would fence as veterans if their preferences are generally accepted.
All numeric values given for the veteran preferences are out of 10 – a ‘perdecage’ rather than a percentage – and in this summary are the national response only. In the full results, the preferences were broken down further into cities (Auckland, Wellington, Christchurch, Dunedin) and age groups (40-49, 50-59, 60+).
Equipment questions. Do you have, or would you buy: level 2 equipment? – 6; level 1 equipment? – 5; or neither, using older or lesser equipment? – 3. Notes: More fencers have, or would buy, level 2 equipment. About half the fencers have, or would buy, level 1 equipment. More fencers in the 40-49 age group have, or would buy, level 1 and/or level 2 equipment. While level 2 equipment is required for higher level competitions, fencers who already have level 1 equipment may not want to buy level 2 equipment as well to only enter lower level competitions.
Competition questions. Would you compete at a: higher level with ranking? – 5; middle level with ranking? – 8; lower level without ranking? – 8. Notes: More fencers would compete at middle and lower levels rather than a higher level. The three age groups are about equal in this opinion. While Direct Elimination is required for higher level competitions, some older fencers would prefer sequential pools for lower level competitions. This provides more bouts for those with lower ability.
Travel questions. Would you travel to these central cities to compete: Auckland? – 7; Wellington? – 8; Christchurch? – 8; Dunedin? – 7; an overseas city? – 6. Notes: The further a central city is away in New Zealand, the less a fencer will travel to it to compete. The willingness to travel increases with age. Auckland fencers will travel overseas more than others; Dunedin fencers will travel overseas least.
Alternative question. Are you interested in Veterans/Masters visual fencing with rules prior to the introduction of electric foil? – 6. Notes: About half the fencers are interested in this alternative. While the result is skewed somewhat by Salle Angelo fencers in Dunedin, there is still a significant national response.
Conclusion. One solution for Veterans/Masters fencing in New Zealand is to have two competitive formats that run in parallel, where a fencer can move from one to another. A higher level for the younger and truly competitive fencers would be to FIE rules with level 2 equipment, Direct Elimination and a national veterans ranking. A lower level for older and recreational fencers would have level 1 equipment, sequential pools and no national veterans ranking. The enjoyment of the day would be sufficient.